| Produc- tion # | Opening Date | Play | Director | Musical Director | Venue |
| 1 | 22-Mar-47 | Penny Wise | Fred Scheff | Lincoln School, New Providence | |
| 2 | 24-Jan-48 | Claudia | Fred Scheff | Jonathan Dayton Regional High School, Springfield | |
| 2a | 20-May-48 | The Dragon Who Giggled (C) | Desiree Cummings | Lincoln School, New Providence/Mt. Carmel School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 3 | 3-Dec-48 | Ladies in Retirement | Fred Scheff | Jonathan Dayton Regional High School, Springfield | |
| 4 | 27-Jan-50 | Three One-Act Plays: (A) | Columbia School, Berkeley Heights | ||
| 4a | 27-Jan-50 | Polly Patchwork (Y) | Fred Scheff | Columbia School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 4b | 27-Jan-50 | The Dear Departed | Fred Scheff | Columbia School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 4c | 27-Jan-50 | Curse You, Jack Dalton | W. Robert Powers | Columbia School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 5 | 5-May-50 | Ring Around Elizabeth | Fred Scheff | Columbia School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 6 | 17-Nov-50 | Ramshackle Inn | Fred Scheff | Columbia School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 7 | 27-Apr-51 | For Love or Money | Fred Scheff | Columbia School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 8 | 2-Nov-51 | Blithe Spirit | Fred Scheff | Columbia School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 9 | 1-Feb-52 | A Doll's House | Fred Scheff | Columbia School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 9a | 14-Mar-52 | Gloria Mundi (T) | Fred Scheff | Connecticut Farm School, Union | |
| 9b | 4-Apr-52 | Thanksgiving for Frieda (Y) | Unknown | Columbia School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 10 | 23-May-52 | Dear Ruth | Fred Scheff | Columbia School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 11 | 14-Nov-52 | Goodbye, My Fancy | Fred Scheff | Columbia School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 12 | 17-Apr-53 | The Happiest Years | Fred Scheff | Columbia School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 13 | 20-Nov-53 | Suspect | Fred Scheff | Columbia School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 14 | 21-May-54 | Over Twenty-One | Fred Scheff | Columbia School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 15 | 19-Nov-54 | The Male Animal | Fred Scheff | Columbia School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 16 | Apr-55 | Arsenic and Old Lace | Fred Scheff | Unknown | |
| 17 | Jun-55 | Sabrina Fair | Frank Symes | Unknown | |
| 18 | Nov-55 | The Fifth Season | Frank Symes | Unknown | |
| 19 | May-56 | Night Must Fall | Frank Symes | Unknown | |
| 20 | Dec-56 | The Man Who Came to Dinner | Fred Scheff | Unknown | |
| 21 | May-57 | The Tender Trap | Frank Symes | Unknown | |
| 22 | Nov-57 | The Silver Whistle | Fred Scheff | Unknown | |
| 23 | Jun-58 | The Desk Set | Frank Symes | Unknown | |
| 24 | Nov-58 | Rebecca | Frank Symes | Unknown | |
| 25 | Jun-59 | Janus | Frank Symes | Unknown | |
| 26 | Nov-59 | Pygmalion | Jean Evans | Unknown | |
| 27 | Jun-60 | King of Hearts | Jean Evans | Unknown | |
| 28 | Nov-60 | Third Best Sport | Fred Scheff | Unknown | |
| 29 | May-61 | Born Yesterday | Fred Scheff | Unknown | |
| 30 | Dec-61 | Guest in the House | Jean Henry | Unknown | |
| 31 | May-62 | Harvey | Doug Brush | Unknown | |
| 32 | Nov-62 | Three One-Act Plays: (A) | Unknown | ||
| 32a | Dec-62 | Glory in the Flower | Mae and Dick Gould | Unknown | |
| 32b | Dec-62 | Sorry, Wrong Number | Sue Wadas | Unknown | |
| 32c | Dec-62 | The Flattering World | Tom Allan | Unknown | |
| 33 | 10-May-63 | The Pajama Game | Tom Allan | Unknown | |
| 34 | 6-Dec-63 | Come Blow Your Horn | Dick Gould | Unknown | |
| 35 | 22-May-64 | The Bells Are Ringing | Tom Allan | Unknown | |
| 36 | 4-Dec-64 | Send Me No Flowers | Jean Evans | Unknown | |
| 37 | 14-May-65 | Wake Up Darling | Bill Mathews | Unknown | |
| 38 | 29-Oct-65 | Guys and Dolls | Jean Evans | Governor Livingston High School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 39a | 12-Mar-66 | The Fox in a Fix | Unknown | Governor Livingston High School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 39 | May-66 | Mary, Mary | Jean Evans | Governor Livingston High School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 40 | Oct-66 | You Can't Take It With You | Jean Evans | Governor Livingston High School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 40a | 11-Mar-67 | The Red Key | Unknown | Governor Livingston High School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 41 | 1-May-67 | Never Too Late | Doug Brush | Governor Livingston High School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 42 | 20-Oct-67 | How to Succeed in Business Without Even Trying | Jean Evans | Governor Livingston High School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 42a | Feb-68 | Family Album | Unknown | Governor Livingston High School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 42b | Mar-68 | The Kingdom of the Tiger | Unknown | Governor Livingston High School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 43 | 3-May-68 | The Night of the Iguana | Fred Whalen | Governor Livingston High School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 44 | 18-Oct-68 | The Pen Is Deadlier | Mary Lehne | Governor Livingston High School, Berkeley Heights | |
| 44a | 1-Feb-69 | The Seasick Pirate (C) | Mary Lehne | Kevin Farrell | New Providence High School |
| 44b | 22-Mar-69 | The Persian Peacock (C) | Ron Getto | Lisa Lehne | New Providence High School |
| 45 | 3-May-69 | Barefoot in the Park | Ellen Kissenberth | Unknown | |
| 46 | 24-Oct-69 | The Music Man | Frank Rizzo | Al Rubbo | Unknown |
| 47 | 17-Apr-70 | Cactus Flower | Jean Evans | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 48 | 6-Nov-70 | The Odd Couple | Faye Matthews | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 48a | Feb-71 | Bridges … Are When You Cross Them (C) | Mary Lehne | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 49 | 26-Feb-71 | Chamber Music | John Dunnell | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 50 | 30-Apr-71 | Any Wednesday | John Dunnell | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 51 | 5-Nov-71 | Blithe Spirit | Walter Talley | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 51a | 12-Feb-72 | Hawaiian Wickiwicki | Fred Whalen | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 52 | 5-May-72 | All My Sons | Bob Olson | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 53 | 3-Nov-72 | The Absence of a Cello | Jo Ray | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 53a | 16-Feb-73 | Electra - A Revenge | Walter Talley | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 54 | Mar-73 | A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum | Nancy Andrews/Fred Whalen | Ginny Ward | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren |
| 55 | 9-Nov-73 | Fiorello! | Nancy Andrews | Ginny Ward | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren |
| 56 | Feb-74 | Last of the Red Hot Lovers | John Mielskalski | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 57 | 19-Apr-74 | Stop the World, I Want to Get Off | John Dunnell | Harry Ailster | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren |
| 57a | 3-May-74 | The High White Star (Y) | Carolyn Thomas | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 58 | Oct-74 | Rashomon | John Dunnell | Unknown | |
| 59 | 18-Oct-74 | 6 Rms Riv Vu | Judy Nazemetz | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 59a | 7-Dec-74 | The Invention | Fred Whalen | New Providence High School | |
| 60 | 7-Feb-75 | One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest | Ron Getto | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 60a | 14-Mar-75 | The Night of January 16th (Y) | Barbara Kadri(?) | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 61 | 2-May-75 | Company | Mia Anderson | Harry Ailster | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren |
| 62 | 17-Oct-75 | How the Other Half Loves | Frank Ragazzo | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 62a | Dec-75 | Harvey (Y) | Unknown | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 63 | 10-Jan-76 | Circus in the Wind (C) | Nina Deutz | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 64 | Feb-76 | Star Spangled Girl | F. Shulman/Maryellen Calvert | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 65 | 7-May-76 | Wildcat | Nancy Andrews | Ginny Ward | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren |
| 66 | 12-Nov-76 | See How they Run | Frank Ragazzo | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 66a | 8-Dec-76 | You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown (Y) | Tony Susczcynski | Linda Calvert | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren |
| 67 | 14-Jan-77 | When You Comin' Back, Red Ryder? | John Dunnell | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 67a | 14-Jan-77 | Hold Me (Y) | Francine Fiore | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 68 | 25-Feb-77 | An Enemy of the People | Mark Churchill | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 69 | 6-May-77 | Anything Goes | Nancy Andrews | Lew Howell | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren |
| 70 | 7-Oct-77 | Dial M for Murder | David Mead | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 71 | 12-Nov-77 | The Roar of the Greasepaint… the Smell of the Crowd | Frank Ragazzo | Linda Calvert | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren |
| 71a | 2-Jan-78 | Dementia (Y) | Joe Cybalski | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 72 | 13-Jan-78 | Habeas Corpus | John Dunnell | Linda Calvert | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren |
| 73 | 17-Feb-78 | Lovers and Other Strangers | Tom Lanno | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 74 | 5-May-78 | Carnival | Nancy Andrews | Ginny Ward | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren |
| 75 | 27-Oct-78 | Of Mice and Men | Frank Ragazzo | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 75a | 2-Dec-78 | Johnny Moonbeam and the Silver Arrow (C) | Linda Behrle | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 76 | 23-Feb-79 | Luv | Tom Lanno | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 77 | 4-May-79 | Kiss Me Kate | Nancy Andrews | Ginny Ward/Linda Calvert | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren |
| 77a | 14-Sep-79 | The Skin of Our Teeth (Y) | Doug Eaton | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 78 | 26-Oct-79 | The Effect of Gamma Rays on Man-in-the-Moon Marigolds | Tom Lanno | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 79 | 22-Feb-80 | Black Comedy | Mary Lehne | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 80 | 2-May-80 | Pippin | Linda Behrle | Ginny Ward | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren |
| 80a | 26-Sep-80 | Night Watch (Y) | Joann Churchill | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 81 | 7-Nov-80 | The Best Man | Mary Lehne | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 81a | 8-Dec-80 | Once Upon a Christmas (C) | Linda Behrle | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 81b | 2-Jan-81 | Impromptu (Y) | Unknown | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 81c | 2-Jan-81 | The Freezer (Y) | Unknown | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 81d | 2-Jan-81 | The Sisters McIntosh (Y) | Unknown | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 82 | 20-Feb-81 | Seven Keys to Baldpate | Mary Lehne | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 83 | 1-May-81 | The Rainmaker | Joann Churchill | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 84 | 6-Nov-81 | South Pacific | Mary Lehne | Henry Wyatt | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren |
| 84a | 12-Dec-81 | Winnie the Pooh (Y) | Anne Burgdorff | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 85 | 19-Feb-82 | Wait Until Dark | Mary Lehne | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 86 | 7-May-82 | The Murder Room | Joann Churchill | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 87 | 5-Nov-82 | Man of La Mancha | Rick Engler/Joann Churchill | Peter Bridges | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren |
| 88 | 25-Feb-83 | Rain | Doug Eaton | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 89 | 6-May-83 | Shay | Joann Churchill | Stony Hill Playhouse, Warren | |
| 90 | Oct-83 | The Pajama Game (w/ Scotch Plains Players) | Richard Engler | Unknown | St. Bart's Church, Scotch Plains |
| 91 | Feb-84 | The Lion in Winter | Doug Eaton | American Legion Hall, New Providence | |
| 92 | May-84 | Catch Me If You Can | Frank Ragazzo | American Legion Hall, New Providence | |
| 93 | Oct-84 |